Sunday, April 14, 2013

More than just being tired?

I picked up the following off the Medical Post otherwise known as the Medical Enquirer who email me a digest of news unsolicited everyday (I could block them, I guess)
There was a sigh of relief across the country in 2011 when a Quebec arbitrator ruled that the 24-hour shifts required of medical residents violated the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Finally, there was recognition that this treatment of neophyte doctors not only violated their health, but the safety of patients. Doctors shared stories of car accidents after long shifts and of mistakes made in the daze of exhaustion.Key thinkers on health care called it a common-sense ruling. A few months later, Quebec capped on-call duty for residents at 16 hours, down from 24. With mounting evidence about the adverse effects of long-call shifts, it seemed like a move the rest of Canada should follow.Or maybe not, new research suggests.Two studies in the Journal of the American Medical Association argue that the 16-hour limit might not actually improve the lives of residents or the safety of patients. In fact, it may make matters worse.A longitudinal cohort study, published in JAMA, used a first-year resident health survey to track the effects of 2011 duty-hour reforms in the U.S. (which, like Quebec, limited call to 16 hours but only for first-year trainees). Dr. Srijan Sen, a psychiatry professor at the University of Michigan who led the study, told Science-ish that his data busts assumptions. Shorter shifts did not lead to more sleep—nor did it improve the well-being of residents. In fact, they made more medical errors. “There are unintended consequences—negative consequences—associated with capping hours,” he said.For example, most hospital residency programs didn’t have the resources to hire new physicians or physicians’ assistants, so residents were expected to do about the same amount of work in less time. Dr. Sen linked the resulting “work compression” to medical error. “There’s clear evidence that working so long isn’t good for cognitive functioning. But it looks like we’re creating new problems by cutting down those shifts.”The second JAMA study looked at medical house staff at Johns Hopkins Hospital, randomly assigning them to a 30-hour cap, or to one of two groups with a 16-hour cap. The investigators used wrist watches that measure movements to find out if the groups working fewer hours managed to catch more sleep. The lead author, Dr. Sanjay Desai of Johns Hopkins, told Science-ish that the interns who worked less slept an average of three hours more around the period during which they took call, but otherwise got no more sleep than the control group.“Is three hours enough sleep to change levels of fatigue and response times?” he asked. “For us, this introduced potential flaws in the logic that if you cap hours, people will sleep more, and meaningfully more. That doesn’t seem to hold true based on the data we have.”There were other alarm bells. Dr. Desai says residents who worked night shifts felt their education was compromised, since learning and educational activities generally slow down at night. Hand-offs in the 16-hour groups increased between 130 to 200 per cent compared to the previous 30-hour model. As a result, patients were juggled between more doctors than before. (It’s well known that transitions of care can be akin to a game of broken telephone, a major source of medical error.)So what now?Dr. Chris Landrigan, a professor at Harvard Medical School, who did asystematic review on the effects of the 16-hour call, said most literature points to reducing shifts, and notes serious limitations in the designs of the new studies. The first by Dr. Sen relied on self-reporting of medical errors, well-being and sleep patterns. Dr. Desai’s study also made no direct measure of patient safety. Instead, investigators looked at sleep and hand-offs, which weakens the argument that caps lead to more errors.Still, some of the findings in the JAMA studies have been illustrated by the Quebec experience.Dr. Charles Dussault is president of the Fédération des médecins résidents du Québec, which represents the province’s medical residents. The FMRQ is trying to find ways to supplement education in the OR after surgical residents complained they weren’t learning enough. ”OR time is precious,” he explained. “Some of the models we proposed limited the number of hours residents can spend in the OR.”Quebec doctors have also reported concerns about the increase in hand-offs. “People are feeling the fact that there is more patient transfers than there were before could increase the risk of mistakes.” Dr. Dussault said hospitals are looking for ways to improve hand-offs. “We are still in transition,” he added. “People had the same debate when they went from a 72-hour cap to 36, from 36 to 24, and now from 24 to 16.”And that’s exactly it: shift length is a systems challenge that requires a systems solution. Resident duty hours need to be more humane, but cutting hours without redesigning the hospital infrastructure—standardizing hand-offs, addressing work compression or paying attention to resident education—won’t get doctors very far.Both Drs. Sen and Desai pointed out that it wasn’t just the shrinking of shifts that may have increased errors; it was the lack of planning and organization around the changes. Importantly, they cautioned against the 16-hour limit, noting it was too prescriptive — that a one-size-fits-approach is not suitable for every hospital.In Canada there is currently no consensus on the regulation of duty hours. We can do better. Somewhere between the U.S. and Quebec is a model for the way forward. 
There may be a few explanations.

They mention the issue of hand-overs and unfortunately the quality of communication between doctors is not that great; something medical schools need to work on.

Maybe 16 hours is too long a shift, maybe we should look at 8 or 12.

Our department has for years covered night call on a 1600 - 0700 basis.  Let me tell you, a lot of nights when I have to do something at 0400, I am pretty shaky (some nights not so much).  Not that I have knowingly done anything bad; I tend to just simplify things and go a little slower.  Maybe we need to teach doctors shift work management or how to work when tired.  Unlike a lot of shift workers, most of us sleep poorly if we have to sleep during the day; I can rarely manage more than a two hour nap without the aid of pharmaceuticals.  That is assuming you have the opportunity to nap at at.  There are a lot of other factors; how busy were you in the first 8 hours, were you woken from a deep sleep etc, how boring what you are doing is.

Are we talking big or little mistakes.  If you are doing a study on errors, you obviously want to have as many errors as possible.  So if for example I give the little old lady 200 mg of propofol when I only should have  to given her 150 mg and have to give her phenylephrine for her BP of 60, is this a significant error.  Are we just measuring a lot of trivial errors with no global effect, just because we can?  Further because medicine is an art not a science, many errors are just judgments which could have gone either way.

Patients are sicker after hours, procedures are more complex there is most opportunity for error no matter how well rested you are.  Because of the hierarchical system that still exists in medicine, more junior staff will be working after hours with less supervision.

And anyway do we have to make patient safely a justification for not making somebody work 24-36 hours or can we just say in civilized society, that is not how we should train people?

Just a few thoughts.

Monday, April 1, 2013

In the trenches.


As I previously blogged we are in a fee dispute with our government who want to cut remuneration to specialists in particular anaesthesiologists in order to redistribute the money to physicians who are "working in the trenches", meaning family docs, geriatricians and psychiatrists.  One of my colleagues copied me on a letter he sent to the president of our union and I really could not have said it better.
So to hear that I'm now being told to take a 25% pay cut and be insulted every second day by this minister really rubs me the wrong way. He has said that he needs to support the "workers in the trenches" (family practice, gerontology, psychiatry) and this causes me to scratch my head. If looking after a young pregnant woman with PIH at three am is not "In the trenches" what am I doing then? Missing my kids soccer games, dance recitals or just bedtime because I am on call? 

There are few lucky anaesthesiologists who work in cosmetic suites, dental offices or just do arthroscopies and ACL repairs on health ASA 1 and 2 patients.  These are a very small minority.  For most of us we take whatever comes in through the door and try to get as good a result as we can.  Not to sound bitter but our job is made one hell of a lot more difficult by those front line "in the trenches" family docs, geriatricians, emergency docs, (don't get me started on internists) etc who haven't worked up their patients properly, haven't treated their medical concerns and often sat on their obvious problems, turning what should have been an urgent procedure done during the day into an emergency in the middle of the night.  And unlike most specialists in our city, when an anaesthesiologist is on call, he is in the hospital caring for a patient or else he is at home, on a 30 minute leash, NOT sitting around having residents and hospitalists look after his patients for him.

Not to mention that when you phone most GPs offices now, after hours or even during the day, you get a message telling you to go to the nearest emergency room or call 911.  (Of course they can't take your phone call, they're busy out in the trenches!)  At least in the city now and in a significant amount of the country, GPs no longer do house calls, work in the emergency, deliver babies, work in hospitals or do nursing home visits.  So who the hell is in the trenches?  Not the person doing well-baby care from 9-5 and weekdays.  Geriatricians, who are for the most part GPs who took a weekend course, are insulated from any patient care by layers of nurse practitioners.  I don't see a lot of them at night in the hospital.

In defense of GPs or as they like to be called, Family Doctors, they were largely forced out of hospitals, emergency rooms and obstetrical units over the past 30 years that I have been in practice.  I don't remember a lot of kicking and screaming but it did happen.  They certainly have never gotten much respect for anybody, have been blamed for much of the increase in healthcare costs in past and had to put up with practice restrictions.  And quite a few of them do provide reasonably good care for their patients.  And unlike my generation who got a one year hospital based rotating internship where they saw lots of sick patients, FPs now go thru a two year family practice "residency' where they predominantly work with academic family docs and learn how to deal with healthy people and wash their hands of everything else.

Working in a quasi community/teaching hospital one realizes how much infrastructure is necessary for doctors to do their jobs and it is these people who are actually in the trenches.  This includes residents, hospitalists, nurse practitioners, physios, lab etc all of whom insulate doctors from their patients.  These people are the real people who are in the trenches and I don't think any of them are going to see the money that is about to be stripped off me.

Every doctor of course thinks what he does is the most important thing in the world and the best strategy from a government point of view is to get us fighting over who gets paid how much for what.

Sunday, March 17, 2013

Frivolous Complaints

I cut and pasted the below from the Medical Post which sends me daily an unsolicited email with a link to its stories.  Unfortunately it is subscription only so I can't give out the link.
VANCOUVER | A patient who was offended because an eye surgeon sang during a medical procedure won’t be seeing the physician get an official sanction.
British Columbia’s Health Professions Review Board, who agreed with a previous ruling from the provincial college, dismissed the complaint in January.
The doctor had been called “arrogant” for singing, but the board disagreed with the patient.
“The complainant says that the registrant’s conduct of singing and talking about taking left-over hospital towels to wash his car while putting a ‘lense’ into his right eye is unacceptable, arrogant, disrespectful and shameful,” wrote review board chair David A. Hobbs in the decision.
Initially, the patient complained to the B.C. College of Physicians and Surgeons following the procedure, which occurred at a hospital on May 20, 2011.
The male complainant said the doctor was chatting about using hospital towels to wash his car and that he sang as he worked on the patient.
College spokesperson Susan Prins said officials took a look at the complaint, but found the patient’s care had not been compromised.
“The college does not have specific rules about singing in the OR, but physicians should be certainly be mindful of their actions and words during any procedure,” Prins told the CBC.
But when the college dismissed the claim against the doctor, the patient pressed on and took his complaint to the Review Board.
But the board said the complaint was “trivial.”
Neither the doctor nor the patient have been identified, due to privacy concerns.

For about the last 10 years or so, regulatory bodies like the Colleges (Medical Boards) and hospital patient concerns offices have had to deal with each complaint no matter how trivial.  This means now that since as department head every time we get one of these complaints, I have to meet with the individual and then write a response to their complaint. For this the hospital pays me handsomely.  The most recent complaint that I dealt with, was a patient with Mulitple Chemical Sensitivities who complained, even though the anaesthesiologist gave her the anaesthetic exactly the way she wanted (total intravenous anaesthesia avoiding all the drugs she claimed to be sensitive to), apparently because the anaesthesiologist tried to explain to her than Sevoflurane actually doesn't have any preservatives.  I wrote a letter to the Chief of Staff stating that only the most saintly and patient physician would have gotten any other outcome.

Not only did this individual get to complain to the provincial College (Medical Board) but when they rejected his concern, presumably after considering it carefully, the province had nicely set up at considerable expense, another board to hear his complaint.  I wonder how many nurses could be hired for the cost of maintaining this little board.

In the course of my work I frequently come across patients who have really been treated shabbily by our system and unfortunately quite frequently by some of my colleagues and occasionally I suggest that they should really complain about the way they were treated.  Most of them even ones who have actually suffered injuries at the hands of the healthcare system are reluctant to do this.  This leaves the trivial complaints.

Fortunately most surgeons don't sing in the OR anymore.  I remember more sang when I was younger.  I am sure some surgeons have beautiful voices and good  tastes in music; these individuals largely didn't sing much, it was the ones that thought they were good singers who sang. (A gynaecologist who played the organ in his church whistled during his cases; you could tell what he was going to be playing that Sunday.)  Largely instead of singing now surgeons spend most of the case talking about their perfect family, their perfect vacation, their car or their right wing politics.

Having listen to this as a patient while awake could be disturbing, sort of like going to the dentist except the surgeon isn't asking you a bunch of questions while there is a bunch of stuff in your mouth and you can't really reply although you feel obliged to do so.

And really who gives a shit if the surgeon is taking the disposable towels home to wash his car; at least they are making one more stop before going to the landfill.

Sunday, February 17, 2013

"Emergencies"

Once again Great Zs has unlocked my writer's block.

About a month ago our friendly Patients Concerns Office sent me a little letter.   Apparently the relatively of a patient with a fractured hip wrote to complain that her loved one had waited 3 days to have his fractured hip repaired.  Moreover he had been put on the list every single one of those days which meant fasting until he was cancelled late in the evening.  This of course had to be anaesthesia's fault so I investigated.

First I got our head nurse to send me a print-out of every "emergency" case done during those three days.  I suddenly noticed a funny thing.  Saturday, day one of his ordeal was a pretty busy day with lots of ortho and other "emergencies".  Sunday however everything suddenly stopped around 1400.  This was indeed curious as one of the most mercenary orthopods was on call.  I then realized what had happened on this day.  It was Canada's version of the Super Bowl, the Grey Cup and the orthopod wanted to watch the game.

This of course wasn't the reason why the patient waited until Monday night.  The real reason was that his PT INR hadn't come down until then.   As I told the nice Patient Concerns lady, I have told ortho and their hospitalists multiple times NOT to book patients until their coags are normal and we go thru this little dance of booking and then cancelling patients just about every day (not infrequently because somebody forgot to stop their coumadin).

At our little hospital it is possible to predict how busy a day will be just by which surgeons are on call. .  We have the mercenary ortho surgeon above but we also have several general surgeons who bring in cholecystectomies off their wait list when they are on call.  They also book colon cancers as bowel obstructions.  Our hospital has been designated as the kidney stone centre for the region which means when one of a group of 3 urologists is on call, their office will book 4-5 patients.  These patients will come in as "day patients" at around 0900 which means you just can't run off one or two first thing in the morning while everybody else is getting their act together.  Instead the urologist waltzes in around 0930 expecting to go ahead of  everybody else, having booked his cases Friday morning.

Appendixes are another thing of course.  These are never emergencies between 0700 and 1600 on weekdays when it would mean bumping a general surgery room.  At 1600 however a general surgeon will be at the desk demanding that they be done immediately or else they will surely die (that is unless he has a gall bladder or a "bowel obstruction" to do first).

Things are tight, the population is older and sicker and the number of OR rooms hasn't really changed much in the last 20 years so I can see why surgeons might want to play these games.  On the other hand it is when we have a real emergency come thru the door that the shit literally hits the fan and it is usually anaesthesia and nursing who have to sort out the mess.  Not to mention the poor anaesthesiologist slogging away on some real or imagined emergency late in the evening.

Sunday, January 13, 2013

Queue jumping


In Canada we have waiting lists.  This means that depending on the procedure or service you want, you may wait anywhere from 2 days to 2 years.  There is much hand-wringing about this, however life goes on, overall we get pretty good care and except for a few of what our former premier called victims of the week, nobody suffers all that much.

As a poison pill for his successors Stephen Duckett the former CEO of our health authority mentioned that in Alberta, there were members of the administration who were the "go to" guys for important people or squeaky wheels to get the head of the line and not have to suffer along with the great unwashed.  Dr. Duckett did this sometime before he got fired for doing this.

As a result of promises made during her leadership campaign plus desperate promises made when it looked like she was going to lose the election, we now have a commission into preferential access or as we commonly refer to it, "queue jumping".   This is enriching at least one retired judge and multiple lawyers to the tune of about $10 million,money that will never be spent on patient care.  It has to date been tremendously unproductive with people testifying that they had heard rumours of influential people getting special treatment but nobody is naming names.  This is not surprising as physicians and most health care workers are prohibited by various codes of ethics from divulging patient names and in fact the first doctor or nurse to name names is going to be getting a letter from their professional body.

But of course we all know that queue jumping goes on and that influential patients do get treated sooner than ordinary patients.  This is partially controlled by doctor's offices who after all decide in what order their surgeries will be done or whether or not to squeeze another patient into their busy day.  From conversations in the doctor's lounge many surgeons have stories about being asked to assess or treat an important person in a more timely fashion and who would disagree as after all they are important people.

As an anaesthesiologist I have very little to do with waiting lists (except that we all know if only anaesthesia would worker harder for more hours we wouldn't have waiting lists), however I do run a pain clinic with a fairly significant wait list.   And I let people queue jump all the time.  If a nurse asks me to see her or a relative early, I always try to help.  Likewise other doctors.  If we can't help each other, nobody is going to.  If a family doctor takes the time to phone me about a patient (instead of the usual unhelpful letters I get), I often put their patient in early.  Some family doctors, I know provide good service so I am more favourably inclined towards their patients.  I also try to take care of the patients of my fellow specialists in my hospital.  When another pain specialist wants a second opinion (this doesn't happen very often) I see them sooner.  Further I try to review my referrals and certain cases get seen urgently (this is actually triage which I will talk about below).  Face it another healthcare worker or relative of one is likely to actually attend their appointment and might even take your advice.

Further I have myself taken advantage of queue jumping.  When my kids broke a bone (or I thought they had broken a bone), instead of sitting in the emergency room  I just phone or talk to an orthopedic surgeon.  When my son broke his ankle on a Friday afternoon and I got the phone call at work I had visions of spending my Friday evening in the ER, until I thought why don't I just talk to the ortho on call who told me to just come to the ER as a direct to him.  As it turned out the ER was not very busy but the orthopod was very helpful for my son's non-displaced ankle fracture.  This is as opposed to the 2 or 3 times I decided to play by the rules and took my son to the ER and learned how badly the general public gets treated.  (After being spoken to very condescendingly by the family doc covering ER, I mentioned "Oh did you know I am a doctor, too?".  It was almost worth it,  just to see the look on his face).

When I needed a screening colonoscopy I could have wasted time going to my GP, and getting a referral.  Why would I do that.  I just phoned the gastroenterologist who got me in the following Monday (I would have been happy to have waited longer, honest).  Five years later, I sat down next to one the General Surgeons in the doctor's lounge and arranged my second screening colonoscopy.  When I hurt my shoulder, I got an MRI within two weeks of the surgeon requesting it; I never asked why that was.

The fact that doctors do this is one of the things that has come out in the inquiry and judging by letters to the editor, some of the public are upset that this happens.  My advice: get over it.

It was a sports medicine doctor who during the inquiry pointed out that with the long wait lists for various procedures, that it was only natural  that some degree of queue jumping would go on and that this wasn't necessarily a bad thing.   He hit the nail on the head.  This isn't in fact queue jumping, it is called prioritization or triage.

Imagine if the ER just saw everybody in the order in which they checked in.  MIs would wait for hours while all the colds got seen.  An extreme analogy?  That is how elective surgery and imaging is triaged in most of Canada.  This effectively means the young active patient needing say an ACL repair waits behind the octagenarian waiting for a total hip even though the young patient is an active member of society whereas the octagenarian may just be turning food into shit.  Every time I get the BMI of 50 or the cardiac cripple presenting for a total joint, I ask the surgeon, "I thought you had a waiting list?"  (or I think I so ask them).  It is the unwillingness of physicians to triage or prioritize patients that exacerbates the effect of the wait list.  People cry foul when a professional hockey player gets an MRI or surgery toute de suite.  I have absolutely no problem with this.  Notwithstanding whether I agree with how much a professional hockey player earns, they do depend on their body for work and I would rather they have their knee MRIed  than somebody with migraines getting an MRI that everybody knows will be normal.  Likewise if the surgeon wants to do their ACL repair instead of doing 3 arthroscopies on obese patients in their 60s, more power to him.  The same applies to elite athletes, I have no problem with their getting seen and treated sooner.

I am 55 and proudly got my first senior's discount last month.  If however I tore up my ACL I would happily take my place in line and wait a little if I knew that at least more useful members of society were getting treated a little sooner.   Not every 55 year old thinks this way.

Because of  perceived unacceptable wait times for total joints we now have an aggressive program to reduce those wait lists.  I was at one of the meetings related to this.  Patients when they are booked are given exercises to do that will help them rehab.  According to one of the physiotherapists, only 20% of patients actually do the exercises.  "There", I said, "your wait list problems are solved, you can take 80% of the patients off the list."  "Yes... well" said the nurse chairing the meeting and that was that.  I no longer go to those meetings.

Meanwhile, our Tea Party opposition who advocate patients being able to pay to get to the head of the queue are outraged by patients getting to the head of the queue without paying.

Saturday, January 5, 2013

Hitting the bricks

A very wise and now deservedly retired anaesthesiologist and medical politician told me the following many years ago:

"Negotiating with the government is like having a farting contest with a skunk."

While doctors in Canada are fee for service and some hospitals are nominally private entities; close to 100% of the money we get for medical fees and what the hospitals get for patient care (which affects how much we can bill in a fee for service system) come from various arms of the the government.  Medicare in Canada in Canada now dates back to the 1960s.  This means there is a whole generation of doctors in Canada myself included who have never given a Canadian patient a bill for a medically necessary service.  The odd patient with no coverage that I have to ask for money makes me feel weird, I suspect quite a few doctors just eat the bill and don't even bother billing.  When the rare boob job patient we get at our hospital pays me in $100 bills, I feel really dirty (for a while).  Getting paid almost exclusively by the government is not necessarily a bad thing; having a single payer makes billing really easy and we rarely get stiffed.  And after everything most doctors in Canada do okay and quite a few do very well.

Dealing with the government means every 2-5 years our union, which some people insist on calling a medical society, has to negotiate with the government.  Originally a fee schedule was arrived at with increase that usually more or less followed inflation and no upper limit on the total amount that either individuals or the entire profession could bill.  Predictably as doctors realized how to play the fee schedule and as patients realized that medical care was actually free the amounts spent on physician fees (or salaries as the press and politicians like to call it) exceeded the inflation rate.   Therefore around the time that I started in practice, governments started restricting the amount of money spent on physician services.  Attempts at restricting the amounts that an individual could earn fizzled out when it was realized that people would just stop working when they had reached their cap.   A global cap on physician services was arrived at with the threat of clawing back or pro-rating fees if the cap was exceeded (this to my knowledge has rarely happened in Canada).  Medical associations eventually arrived at sectional caps so that I, for example would not be penalized the the profligate ways of the plastic surgeons.

Periodically it is announced that doctors have gotten a X% fee increase.   This does not mean that I am going to get X% more money next year.  I might get more, I might get less.  Our union, oops medical association takes the money and allocates it to various specialties and procedures.  For example specialties like paediatrics and neurology may get a higher percentage of the fee increase because their overall incomes are less.  Over the last 10 years more of the fees have been directed towards after-hours premiums which are great for people like anesthesiologists who do a lot of work after hours.  We recently negotiated a 25% surcharge for obese (BMI over 35) patients.  Our own section of anaesthesia now has two hourly rates reflecting the various complexities of different cases.  We were also in the process of phasing out our procedure based billing which occasionally allowed anaesthesiologists to make huge fees for a single case.  Not a perfect system but better than what existed 20 years ago.

For those of us not involved in medical politics, while we noticed that our union and the government hadn't yet reached an agreement, we kept on getting paid and nobody was really that worried.  That was until the Minister of Health unilaterally imposed a deal on the medical profession.  At face value and according to the talking points issued by the government we were about to receive a 3 % increase with cost of living increases in the next few years.  That was until the small print was looked at.

Affecting anaesthesia was the elimination of the our higher tier of hourly rates and a 10% reduction in after hours premiums.  The procedure based billing which we should have eliminated years ago is also gone.  Other specialties got hit as well in different ways.  Somebody presumable is getting the extra 3% the government keeps talking about we just haven't figured out who.

This has put our society/union on high alert.  It has resulted in multiple emails from the president; an ad campaign from the government  and talks of striking or withdrawing services.

There is no question that some procedures pay way too much for what is involved, and some specialties make way more that they should for the hours they work and the complexity of the service they provide.  Some could argue that we as anaesthesiologists are over-valued.  Everybody looks at everybody else and undervalues what they do.  It is also true that our medical association has done very little to address these inequities assuming they exist (and they do).

I really don't like getting paid less for the same amount of work and on top of this just before this announcement, I finally figured I could afford to work less and actually quit one of my jobs.  I have a little sympathy with some of my younger and not so younger colleagues who have got themselves into huge mortgages based on the assumption of a certain income.  On the other hand I am a little bemused by the attitude of doctors.

Face it,as a bleeding heart liberal I usually keep my mouth shut when a political discussion breaks out in the doctors lounge.  Quite a few doctors still think that Genghis Khan was a bit of a leftie.  The  past 20 years have been a time of union busting no less in Canada than in the US and announcement of this have usually been received with glee in the forum of the doctors lounge.  All while it is gratifying to learn of the support the general public has for us either in the letters to the editor or in polls commissioned by the medical association; the public is better off not knowing how little the doctors have supported them in the past.
It is all too tempting to quote Martin Niemoller at this time; way too tempting in fact:


First they came for the communists,and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a communist.
Then they came for the socialists,and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists,and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a trade unionist.
Then they came for me,and there was no one left to speak for me.

Doctors of  course will argue that they are not a trade union but independent professionals and they of course are welcome to that delusion.  Some will even argue that without medicare, they would be able to make incomes equal to or exceeding what they make now from the patient's pocket.  This is of course true for  some, however quite a few of my colleagues would starve if patients had to dig into their pockets for the crappy service they provide.  

In the end, I suspect everything will work out, the government will give up something, our union will give up something and life will go on as before.  On the other hand I have gone 55 years without walking a picket line.  

Not that that was on my bucket list.



Thursday, December 20, 2012

What I am really ready for is for people to stop asking me if I am ready for Christmas

I have noticed this trend over the past few years that people around Christmas will attempt to start a conversation or just acknowledge you by asking, "are you ready for Christmas?"  This will include patients, co-workers and people you have only just met, like the man who asked me in the hot tub at the Y tonight.

Just for the record I am ready for Christmas.  I don't have many responsibilities, just try to read my wife's mind and buy her presents of the approximate dollar value to what she buys for me. (I know you read this dear and I love you very much).   It took 3 after work epic shopping sessions but I may have succeeded.  In some ways I am excused by virtue of having to work until December 23.

I also love Christmas.  What's not to love about a week off, knowing the days are going to get longer, getting  and giving presents, being together with your family, being able to shamelessly overeat and drink.  I listen to the all Christmas music radio station and enjoy both the cheesy and ultra traditional songs.  I actually like eggnog.

What I can't understand is why people will ask other people they don't actually know that well or at all if they are ready for Christmas?  I know they are only trying to be friendly but is it any of their business.  For all they  know I may not celebrate Christmas, or may be horribly unready for it (and thanks for reminding me and adding to my stress).   But is Christmas something you have to be ready for or should it be something that just happens. I know those presents don't just buy themselves,the tree doesn't decorate itself and the baking doesn't just happen but have we taken what should be most wonderful time of year (this was playing on the radio as I typed this) and turned it into an event for which one has to be ready.

So.....wishing my a Merry Christmas or Happy Holidays or Winter Solstice is fine.  Just don't ask me if I am ready.  I am but just don't ask.

As an aside I went to a local production of Dickens' "A Christmas Carol" last week.  This is the third time I have seen it since moving here and I have seen it a couple of times elsewhere as well as various movie versions plus I read the book.  So I sort of know the plot.  I was wondering to my wife if maybe they were going to update the plot this year.  Like maybe Scrooge was going to remember his fiduciary duties to his shareholders,  tell Cratchit to pull himself up by his bootstraps while outsourcing his job after which of course he could award himself a huge year end bonus.

A Christmas Carol is more than a play about Christmas.   As I result of the 3 visitations, Scrooge starts to pay Cratchit a living wage, enabling him to purchase medical care for Tiny Tim and starts to donate to charities which in the 19th century were the social safety net.  Sadly most 19th century capitalists didn't do this and things got worse rather than better during the rest of the 19th century for the Cratchits and Tiny Tims.  There were a lot of gains in the 20th century but so many of these have been rolled back.

With that thought, have a Merry Christmas.